[tei-council] listRelation membership in model.biblLike

[Kevin Hawkins]

On 6/4/2013 7:08 PM, Martin Holmes wrote:
> On 13-06-04 02:50 PM, Kevin Hawkins wrote:
>> The wording that confuses Martin was likely borrowed from my comment on
>> the ticket:
>>
>> https://sourceforge.net/p/tei/feature-requests/310/#6aba
>>
>> I'll try rephrasing for clarity:
>>
>> "so that bibl, biblStruct, and biblFull can contain<relation>  elements
>> as children without needing to insert a<relationGrp>  as a child of
>> bibl, biblStruct, and biblFull and then putting the<relation>  elements
>> inside the<relationGrp>."
>
> But<bibl>  (for instance) _cannot_ contain<relation>, can it? And
> neither can<biblStruct>  or<biblFull>. So if that was the intention,
> whatever was done didn't achieve it.
>
> What has been achieved is to allow<listRelation>  and<relationGrp>  to
> appear wherever<bibl>  et al can appear, which is something completely
> different. I'm as puzzled as Lou is by it. Sebastian's argument that
> weirder things pertain elsewhere in the TEI so we should leave well
> alone surely doesn't hold if this is a simple case of an error in ticket
> implementation.

I agree that the ticket was misimplemented.  I believe the error crept 
in based on this summary of the action:

https://sourceforge.net/p/tei/feature-requests/310/?limit=10&page=1#b68c

and the following comment that was implemented according to that 
summary.  But neither matches what was described at:

https://sourceforge.net/p/tei/feature-requests/310/#6aba

I realize this went out 1.5 years ago, but I think it's best if we undo it.

--Kevin