[tei-council] model.respLike. was: Taking another ticket (2976715)

[Martin Holmes]

I'm now implementing this, and there are a couple of issues in the 
second part of the recommendation that need some discussion, I think:

 > 2. Replace explicit references to author | editor | respStmt in the
 > content model of biblStruct with a reference to the model.respLike
 > class, so that <distributor>, <funder>, <sponsor> and <principal> are
 > available where <author>, <editor> and <respStmt> currently are.

By <biblStruct>, we really mean <analytic>, <monogr> and <series>. 
<analytic> is straightforward; we simply replace this:

         <rng:ref name="author"/>
         <rng:ref name="editor"/>
         <rng:ref name="respStmt"/>

with this:

         <rng:ref name="model.respLike"/>

in the existing content model:

   <content>
     <rng:zeroOrMore xmlns:rng="http://relaxng.org/ns/structure/1.0">
       <rng:choice>
         <rng:ref name="author"/>
         <rng:ref name="editor"/>
         <rng:ref name="respStmt"/>
         <rng:ref name="title"/>
         <rng:ref name="ref"/>
         <rng:ref name="date"/>
       </rng:choice>
     </rng:zeroOrMore>
   </content>

<series> is slightly more complicated, in that it has this for its 
content model:

   <content>
     <rng:zeroOrMore xmlns:rng="http://relaxng.org/ns/structure/1.0">
       <rng:choice>
         <rng:text/>
         <rng:ref name="model.gLike"/>
         <rng:ref name="title"/>
         <rng:ref name="ref"/>
         <rng:ref name="editor"/>
         <rng:ref name="respStmt"/>
         <rng:ref name="biblScope"/>
         <rng:ref name="model.global"/>
       </rng:choice>
     </rng:zeroOrMore>
   </content>

<author> is not there, of course; replacing <editor> and <respStmt> with 
model.respLike would have the side-effect of adding <author> as well as 
the other intended items (<sponsor> etc.).

<monogr> is the most complicated of all. Here we have a rather 
rigidly-controlled sequence and structure for the content model:

   <content>
     <rng:group xmlns:rng="http://relaxng.org/ns/structure/1.0">
       <rng:optional>
         <rng:choice>
           <rng:group>
             <rng:choice>
               <rng:ref name="author"/>
               <rng:ref name="editor"/>
               <rng:ref name="respStmt"/>
             </rng:choice>
             <rng:zeroOrMore>
               <rng:choice>
                 <rng:ref name="author"/>
                 <rng:ref name="editor"/>
                 <rng:ref name="respStmt"/>
               </rng:choice>
             </rng:zeroOrMore>
             <rng:oneOrMore>
               <rng:ref name="title"/>
             </rng:oneOrMore>
             <rng:zeroOrMore>
               <rng:choice>
                 <rng:ref name="idno"/>
                 <rng:ref name="editor"/>
                 <rng:ref name="respStmt"/>
               </rng:choice>
             </rng:zeroOrMore>
           </rng:group>
           <rng:group>
             <rng:oneOrMore>
               <rng:choice>
                 <rng:ref name="title"/>
                 <rng:ref name="ref"/>
               </rng:choice>
             </rng:oneOrMore>
             <rng:zeroOrMore>
               <rng:choice>
                 <rng:ref name="idno"/>
                 <rng:ref name="author"/>
                 <rng:ref name="editor"/>
                 <rng:ref name="respStmt"/>
               </rng:choice>
             </rng:zeroOrMore>
           </rng:group>
         </rng:choice>
       </rng:optional>
       <rng:zeroOrMore>
         <rng:choice>
           <rng:ref name="model.noteLike"/>
           <rng:ref name="meeting"/>
         </rng:choice>
       </rng:zeroOrMore>
       <rng:zeroOrMore>
         <rng:ref name="edition"/>
         <rng:zeroOrMore>
           <rng:choice>
             <rng:ref name="idno"/>
             <rng:ref name="editor"/>
             <rng:ref name="respStmt"/>
           </rng:choice>
         </rng:zeroOrMore>
       </rng:zeroOrMore>
       <rng:ref name="imprint"/>
       <rng:zeroOrMore>
         <rng:choice>
           <rng:ref name="imprint"/>
           <rng:ref name="extent"/>
           <rng:ref name="biblScope"/>
         </rng:choice>
       </rng:zeroOrMore>
     </rng:group>
   </content>

The simplest way to proceed would be to replace every instance of editor 
and/or author and/or respStmt with model.respLike; this, again, would 
introduce <author> in a couple of contexts where it's currently excluded 
(where <idno> shares a block with <editor> and <respStmt>). We also have 
an explicit instance of <meeting>, which is also a member of model.respLike.

My own instinct is to go ahead and use model.respLike in both <series> 
and <monogr>, and accept the resulting arrival of <author> where it was 
previously excluded; but I think it's important for the committee to 
give an explicit OK to this, since I don't remember us discussing it in 
detail at the meeting.

What do you think?

Cheers,
Martin

On 11-04-21 12:46 AM, Lou Burnard wrote:
> Yes .. apologies for lack of clarity!
>
> Sent from my HTC
>
> ----- Reply message -----
> From: "Martin Holmes" <mholmes at uvic.ca>
> Date: Thu, Apr 21, 2011 04:24
> Subject: [tei-council] Taking another ticket (2976715)
> To: "TEI Council" <tei-council at lists.village.Virginia.EDU>
>
> Now I come to look at the minutes again, I realize I only understand
> half of this:
>
>  > "Ticket 2976715: We agreed to add<distributor> to model.respLike,
>
> ...got that...
>
>  > and
>  > to use model.respLike within content models passim.
>
> ...but that bit isn't really clear to me. My comment on the ticket in
> October proposed two changes:
>
> 1. Add <distributor> to model.respLike, for consistency with
> <principal>, <funder> and <sponsor>.
>
> 2. Replace explicit references to author | editor | respStmt in the
> content model of biblStruct with a reference to the model.respLike
> class, so that <distributor>, <funder>, <sponsor> and <principal> are
> available where <author>, <editor> and <respStmt> currently are.
>
> Does the second bit in the minutes refer to #2 above?
>
> Cheers,
> Martin
>
> On 11-04-20 10:46 AM, Martin Holmes wrote:
>  > Hi there,
>  >
>  > If no-one objects, I propose to implement this decision from the minutes:
>  >
>  > "Ticket 2976715: We agreed to add<distributor> to model.respLike, and
>  > to use model.respLike within content models passim. The distinction
>  > between intellectual responsibility and responsibility for distrribution
>  > might be sorted out later."
>  >
>  > The second half of that ticket, which asks that "model.respLike be added
>  > to<analytic>,<monogr> and<series>, so that these elements are
>  > available in<biblStruct> citations" was presumably rejected or not
>  > addressed -- does anyone remember which?
>  >
>  > Cheers,
>  > Martin
> _______________________________________________
> tei-council mailing list
> tei-council at lists.village.Virginia.EDU
> http://lists.village.Virginia.EDU/mailman/listinfo/tei-council
>
> PLEASE NOTE: postings to this list are publicly archived

-- 
Martin Holmes
University of Victoria Humanities Computing and Media Centre
(mholmes at uvic.ca)