Reviewers of P4

[Lou Burnard]

By what criteria are we suggesting reviewers?

In my view, they should be people who will produce a good review of P4,
to help in its promotion and distribution and, anove all, their review is
reasonably likely to get published somewhere where it may have some
impact.

I don't know how well these suggestions all match these criteria.

In what journals would we expect to see TEI reviewed? Presumably LLC,
CHum and so on, but surely we ought to be targetting beyond our immediate
community a little?

I think the suggestion of Robin Cover is a very good one, though: he will
definitely do a good write up and it will have a wide outreach.

I think we could suggest some of the names on Tomasz' list as reviewers to
journals though: e.g. I think Michael Beddow would do us a very good
piece for one kind of journal, and Wendell would probably do us a good one
for a different kind of journal.

<p><p><p> On Wed, 22 May
2002, Tomaz Erjavec wrote:

> Tone Merete Bruvik writes:
>  > Dear members of the Board and Council,
>  >
>  > We need suggestions on persons and places we should ask to review the
>  > P4. They will get a fee set of the blue books, and we will ask them
>  > as soon as possible. Please send your suggestions to the list as soon
>  > as possible, no later than the end of May.
>  > --
>  > Tone Merete Bruvik
>
> I went through the recent tei-l archives and - more or less (although
> not only) on the basis of how much and what they have posted -
> could suggest the following:
>
> Michael Beddow <mbnospam at MBEDDOW.NET>
> Charles Muller <acmuller at GOL.COM>
> Wendell Piez <wapiez at MULBERRYTECH.COM>
> Rafal T. Prinke <rafalp at AMU.EDU.PL>
> Ralph Cleminson <cleminson at OSZK.HU>
> Anne Mahoney <amahoney at PERSEUS.TUFTS.EDU>
>
> and how about:
> Robin Cover <robin at ISOGEN.COM>
>
> The reasoning is that folks that have the inclination to post answers
> to the list would make good reviewers.
>
> Best,
> Tomaz
>
> --
> Toma&zcaron; Erjavec          | Dept. of Intelligent Systems E-8
> email: tomaz.erjavec at ijs.si   | Institute "Jozef Stefan"
> www:   http://nl.ijs.si/et/   | Jamova 39, SI-1000, Ljubljana
> fax:   (+386 1) 4251 038      | Slovenia
>