[tei-council] meeting problem

[Kevin Hawkins]

Oh wait ... it actually doesn't invalidate that since we now have 
meeting earlier in the content model.  So now I think Sebastian's fix is 
the best way out.

On 12/3/12 9:50 AM, Kevin Hawkins wrote:
> On 12/3/12 5:21 AM, Lou Burnard wrote:
>> On 03/12/12 10:19, Lou Burnard wrote:
>>> On 03/12/12 10:06, Lou Burnard wrote:
>>> the answer is to remove the occurrence of <meeting> from the content
>>> model where it is given as an alternate for <note>.
>>
>> ... which I see Sebastian has just done.
>
> The problem with doing this is that it invalidates:
>
> <biblStruct>
>   <monogr>
>    <title>Proceedings of a workshop on corpus resources</title>
>    <respStmt>
>     <resp>Programme Organizer</resp>
>     <name>Geoffrey Leech</name>
>    </respStmt>
>    <meeting>DTI Speech and Language Technology Club meeting, 3-4
>       January 1990, Wadham College, Oxford</meeting>
>    <imprint>
>     <pubPlace>Oxford</pubPlace>
>    </imprint>
>   </monogr>
> </biblStruct>
>
> which is given at the end of section 3.11.2.2
> (http://www.tei-c.org/release/doc/tei-p5-doc/en/html/CO.html#COBICOR).
> In this example, the work emanates from Geoffrey Leech and yet the
> <meeting> is included as well.
>
> If we continue to allow this, I suggest that I simply remove <meeting>
> from the content model in the *other* places I added it but add it back
> here.  For this ticket, I was just trying to complete the content model
> of <monogr> to be internally consistent in the TEI.  We weren't
> responding to any request from someone trying to use <monogr> with
> <meeting>.
>
> --Kevin