[tei-council] Fwd: [tei-board] licensing issues
lou.burnard at retired.ox.ac.uk
Wed Sep 28 08:12:01 EDT 2011
On 28/09/11 13:03, Sebastian Rahtz wrote:
> On 28 Sep 2011, at 12:51, Lou Burnard wrote:
>> Compromise is good tho, isnt it?
> I think you're confusing good compromise from bad compromise.
> If you need help deciding which is which, I can advise.
Ah thanks, that would be very helpful. What a good thing we have you
>> Actually, it;s better than that. As far as I can judge from some other
>> Board correspondence on the topic -- unattributably copied below -- the
>> Board is waiting for a decision from the Council.
> so which of you three were going to convey this to Council, I wonder? never mind.
I'm not sure who "you three" are, but I'm guessing it's Laurent's job
formally to convey Board decisions to the Council
> I think there is confusion here. George wants permission to alter the current
> schemas he has in oxygen, as a one-off, to make himself legal. This has no
> affect on future schemas, which George reasonably expects us to issue with
s/affe/effec/ i assume
> a new licence (now that the problem has surfaced). I asked JU to take
> executive action, and grant him that one-off licence. I assume thats what the Board
> debated (possibly not in the right context).
Yes, indeed. I think that is the way it worked.
> My sense of the discussion here is that a reasonable number of us are in favour of
> a very simple, very liberal, BSD 2-clause licence for all TEI stuff which the Consortium
> produces. Would anyone vote against that? can I put it up as a strawman proposal
> to see if anyone objects?
"all TEI stuff which the Consortium produces" is a rather vague concept.
In particular it cannot apply prospectively surely? If (perhaps as a
result of the ongoing futures debate) the Consortium gets into some
other line of business -- say developing courseware -- it might want to
licence such activities differently.
I think the proposal needs to be rather more precisely formulated before
it can be voted on,
More information about the tei-council