[tei-council] Tite (was re Influential Blogs?)
lou.burnard at oucs.ox.ac.uk
Thu Mar 25 20:21:58 EDT 2010
O'Donnell, Dan wrote:
> Sorry Sebastian, I've not been expressing myself well all week. Let me
> try again: what I mean is that although in the accessTEI contract we
> specified the Tite ODD rather than a specific schema or DTD as being the
> reference for the programme (after some discussion in Council), it
> turned out that that is not really very practical if the ODD is not
> completely locked down. Like any project, AccessTEI wants its schemas to
> change more slowly than the ODD might, especially if we on council pick
> up and look at some of the ideas for development we've been discussing
> here over the last while.
This makes no sense to me, sorry. The Tite ODD defines the Tite schema
and you can't talk about them independently. The schema is generated
from the ODD. The problem we discussed earlier is that the schema
generated from a given ODD is also determined by the version of the
Guidelines against which the ODD is processed. Hence the requirement to
tie the ODD to a specific release of the Guidelines, as previously
> In addition, the problems caused by defining an ODD by exclusion rather
> than inclusion turned out to be quite serious in constructing a training
> programme for the keyers in India: meaning (at the moment) that we
> needed to do some hand tweaking (removing examples, for example, that
> contained elements not found in Tite or used them in alternate ways when
> Tite restricts prefers one method over the other).
As I already suggested to Perry, and you (I thought) agreed, the right
way to handle this is to supply Tite-specific examples in the ODD. Which
will generate appropriate documentation. And then regenerate the schemas
-- against the right version of the Guidelines!
By the way, I haven't seen any response to my comments of 3 March about
the absence of a header in Tite.
Will we get to discuss this and other problems in the schema when it is
presented to the Council?
More information about the tei-council