[tei-council] Requests 1925125 and 1933198

[Peter Boot]

James Cummings schreef:

> Request 1925125
> (1) we need to define the four new attributes, (@min, @max, at atLeast, 
> @atMost) in a new attribute class, as previously discussed, perhaps 
> "att.ranging" or similar. (The <precision> element mentioned below will 
> then be a member of att.ranging but not att.dimensions.)

I may be missing something very elementary, but what is the intended 
difference between @min and @atLeast? I'd think if x is the minimum 
value for some quantity, that quantity is at least x?

> (2) the existing @precision attribute should be defined within 
> att.dimensions __but **not** att.editLike or att.ranging__. It is really 
> a bug that many of the members of att.editLike currently have @precision.

att.ranging should include the members of att.dimensions, I understand 
from Gabriel's later post. But currently att.dimensions only includes 
these members: depth dimensions height space width. At the last telcon 
we agreed that elements that now have only @extent should also get 
@quantity and @unit, presumably by being included in att.dimensions. 
Does your proposal cover this? Which elements exactly? gap? att.damaged?

Peter