[tei-council] <punctuation>

[Lou Burnard]

On 20/06/13 14:40, Rebecca Welzenbach wrote: Do you agree that 
<punctuation> should instead be a member of model.editorialDeclPart, or 
is there good reason to stick with the original proposal to make it a 
member of model.encodingDescPart?

Yes!


  2) As well as allowing prose content to describe the project's policy 
for handling punctuation marks, we agreed to add some relevant 
attributes. I propose the following: @marks : Just like on <quotation>, 
this would be an optional attribute of the dataype data.enumerated, with 
permitted values of "none", "some", or "all" to indicate whether 
punctuation marks from the source text have been retained in the TEI 
document. @location: this would be an optional attribute, datatype 
data.enumerated, with permitted values of "internal" or "external" to 
indicate whether retained punctuation marks are captured as content 
within adjacent elements or placed outside of them. My model here was 
the use of @location on <variantEncoding>, although the usage of 
"internal" and "external" is not quite consistent between these two. Do 
these two attributes seem appropriate? Sufficient? Suitably named and 
defined?

Plausible propositions both, though maybe @placement would be clearer 
than @location