[tei-council] valList, content etc

[Laurent Romary]

It seems to be close to my feeling on the subject: we need to restrict  
to one single element for all this. Why would not be <content> just  
the good candidate (instead of introducing a new <constraintSpec>)?

Le 9 sept. 09 à 11:00, Sebastian Rahtz a écrit :

> Syd commented to me on this issue to me. See below. I think he is
> right in many ways, but my gut reaction is that this is for ODD 3 not
> our current ODD 2
>
>>
>> That said, my instinct is that it's a reasonable idea. In some sense,
>> what we really want is
>>
>> macro.contentModel = (
>>     element constraintSpec {
>>        attribute scheme { "relaxng" },
>>        (  rng:ref | rng:group | rng:zeroOrMore |
>>           rng:choice | rng:empty | rng:oneOrMore |
>>           rng:text | rng:data | rng:optional )
>>        }
>>     |
>>     element constraintSpec {
>>        attribute scheme { "tei" },
>>        valList
>>        }
>>   ),
>>   element constraintSpec {
>>      attribute scheme { "schematron1.x" },
>>      ( sch:ns | sch:phase | sch:pattern |
>>        sch:rule | sch:report | sch:assert )
>>      }*
>>   element constraintSpec {
>>      attribute scheme { "isoschematron" },
>>      ( isch:ns | isch:phase | isch:pattern |
>>        isch:rule | isch:report | isch:assert )
>>      }*
>>
>> Although we can't use RELAX NG like that, of coures, and I forgot the
>> <constraint> level. (It's the idea that counts. :-) We could use
>> Schematron to enforce some or all of this stuff, though. The
>> flexibility here would permit the list of elements allowed in
>> <constraintSpec scheme="tei"> to expand over time, if that's a
>> direction Council wanted to go in.
>>
>> (BTW, the lists of allowed child elements may well be off by a few
>> here or there -- I didn't do a lot of thinking there. The point is
>> that having a list of elements allowed is more helpful than
>> macro.anyXML. E.g., you don't want to have <sch:schema> or
>> <rng:start> in there.)
>
> --
> Sebastian Rahtz
> Information Manager, Oxford University Computing Services
> 13 Banbury Road, Oxford OX2 6NN. Phone +44 1865 283431
>
> Sólo le pido a Dios
> que el futuro no me sea indiferente
>
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> tei-council mailing list
> tei-council at lists.village.Virginia.EDU
> http://lists.village.Virginia.EDU/mailman/listinfo/tei-council