[tei-council] AMBER for your action

[Arianna Ciula]

2673045  	new attribute @rational on num
YES for @valueType but I would also add in the prose of the guidelines the recommendation to use MathML or similar for complex cases
 
2672530 	Remove repository element requirement in msIdentifier
YES (location is different from repository; this is why we have <adminInfo> to record the eventuality of location different from holding repository)

2640345 	add first and last page recommandation for biblScope
YES (agree with James as said in SourceForge)

2411994 	Define canonical way of referencing TEI element definitions
YES

2242434 	element for text suppressed by the editor 
MAY BE (it's evident from SourceForge comments that we need to discuss this at the meeting)
	
2209933 	content model of 'am' (cf bug 2542813) 	
YES (more discussion needed on content models of similar elements as mentioned)

2055891 	Placement of schematron rules
YES (and more discussion needed after we have a/some proposal/s)

1954920 	@role to be returned to att.naming
MAY BE (yes, in favour of refRole or function as per my comment to the list http://lists.village.virginia.edu/pipermail/tei-council/2009/010348.html)

2493417 	<idno> coverage 	
YES (involve librarian gurus again as for 2411994?)

2607768  	<figure> should be global
YES (I was in favour of this before being member of the council and again especially for manuscript encoding situations, but it will be a pain to find the comment I am thinking of on TEI-L)

2355564 	<figure> should be allowed inside <trailer>
MAY BE (this is related to the one above and may be solved by it or need more discussion)

2542813 	origDate should allow more than text content
YES (with Lou's caveat)

2526505 	content model of <div> eschews <trailer>
MAY BE (no)

Arianna
==
Dr. Arianna Ciula
Science Officer

European Science Foundation 
Humanities Unit
1 quai Lezay Marnésia 
BP 90015
F-67080 Strasbourg
France

Email: aciula at esf.org
Tel: +33 (0) 388767104



-----Original Message-----
From: tei-council-bounces at lists.village.Virginia.EDU [mailto:tei-council-bounces at lists.village.Virginia.EDU] On Behalf Of Lou Burnard
Sent: dimanche 15 mars 2009 13:24
To: TEI Council
Subject: [tei-council] AMBER for your action

Here's the list of open items I've classified as AMBER -- i.e. I don't 
feel we've reached a clear consensus on what to do, either because the 
proposal is a new one not yet reviewed by everyone, or because it's been 
discussed a bit with some toing and froing, but no clear mandate for a 
specific change has yet been agreed on, sfaics.

It would be nice to make as many as possible of these GREEN before next 
week. Could Council members please take a few moments to look at these 
and in the first instance *vote by email* as follows:

YES: change proposed should definitely be implemented
NO: change proposed should definitely not be implemented
MAYBE: change proposed needs further discussion

While I know that everyone will want to add further discussion at the 
same time, it might make tallying the votes easier if you didn't do so 
in the same message. You can of course clarify what you think it is 
you're voting for (or against) if the ticket in question seems vague on 
the topic.

I plan to tally the votes and report back next FRI 20th, but earlier is 
also good. And email commenting on the MAYBEs should be sent without delay.

Some of the older items here have been discussed previously: I apologise 
if the SF ticket doesn't reflect a consensus previously reached. Please 
tell me (offlist) to fix that if necessary.

AMBER Feature Requests

New, not yet discussed:

2673045  	new attribute @rational on num
2672530 	Remove repository element requirement in msIdentifier
2640345 	add first and last page recommandation for biblScope
2411994 	Define canonical way of referencing TEI element definitions

Old: discussed without resolution

2242434 	element for text suppressed by the editor 	
2209933 	content model of 'am' (cf bug 2542813) 	
2055891 	Placement of schematron rules
1954920 	@role to be returned to att.naming
2493417 	<idno> coverage 	

AMBER Bugs

New, not yet discussed:

2607768  	<figure> should be global
2355564 	<figure> should be allowed inside <trailer>
2542813 	origDate should allow more than text content
2526505 	content model of <div> eschews <trailer>
_______________________________________________
tei-council mailing list
tei-council at lists.village.Virginia.EDU
http://lists.village.Virginia.EDU/mailman/listinfo/tei-council