I am not sure what David Horowitz's experiences were with the Vietnam
War but mine included 18 months in the field with the Marines in I Corps
during 1965-67 and later in Japan as a communications supervisor and
cryptographer dealing with highly sensitive information on the war,
among other things.
At the end of the day I was active against the war because:
1. It was justified by the lie that we were there to support democracy
in South Vietnam when in fact the RVN government was probably more
corrupt and less interested in the welfare of its people than that of
2. The war was unwinnable unless we were willing to absorb vastly more
causualties than we did and inflict far more damage on the civilian
population of both the North and South and there was nothing at stake in
Vietnam that justified that degree of slaughter.
3. The military and US political system itself was rotting from the top
down with personal interests taking precedence over commitment to the
constitution and the founding principles of the United States.
When I became very active against the war in while in Japan in 1970 I
did so out of my duty to stand by my oath to uphold and defend the
Constitution, something that the military and political leadership of
the country had abandoned for other agendas.
There were a number of us stationed in Japan at this time who became
active against the war at a time when anti-war activities were sweeping
through the military. It was this resistance from within that brought
the military to its knees as an effective fighting force and no doubt
played a major role in forcing a negotiated peace.
As for the thread on the Black Panthers, even in 1970 in the progressive
circles that I was in there were heated debates on whether they were
revolutionary or just mostly criminal. Personally I could never see how
we could make truly revolutionary advances through glorifying
organizations that engaged in counter-revolutionary criminal acts. The
same can be said for the IRA and other factions in Northern Ireland
which it seems have evolved into drug rings.
Unlike Mr. Horowitz, I remain a progressive with more faith in
social-democratic forms of governance and economics than in the tyranny
of the market place and glorification of greed that drives the corporate
-- Jerry West Editor/publisher/janitor ---------------------------------------------------- THE RECORD On line news from Nootka Sound & Canada's West Coast An independent, progressive regional publication http://www.island.net/~record/
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Wed Jun 14 2000 - 23:05:16 CUT